Title page for ETD etd-07292002-144516

Type of Document Master's Thesis
Author Ehnert, Jesse
Author's Email Address jehnert@vt.edu
URN etd-07292002-144516
Title The Argument from Species Overlap
Degree Master of Arts
Department Philosophy
Advisory Committee
Advisor Name Title
Miller, Harlan B. Committee Chair
FitzPatrick, William J. Committee Member
Klagge, James C. Committee Member
  • ethics
  • nonhuman animals
  • animals
Date of Defense 2002-07-15
Availability unrestricted
The "argument from species overlap" (abbreviated ASO) claims that some human and nonhuman animals possess similar sets of morally relevant characteristics, and are therefore similarly morally significant. The argument stands as a general challenge to moral theories, because many theories hold that all humans possess greater moral significance than all nonhuman animals. In this thesis I discuss responses to the ASO, primarily those of Peter Carruthers, Tom Regan, Evelyn Pluhar, and Peter Singer. Carruthers denies the conclusion of the ASO, while the other three do not. I argue that the ASO is a sound argument, and that Carruthers's attempts to counter it via his contractualist theory are unsuccessful. I next discuss the rights-based theories of Regan and Pluhar, which agree with the conclusion of the ASO but which, I believe, encounter significant theoretical difficulties. Finally, I address the ASO from a utilitarian perspective, first from Singer's utilitarian formulation and then from a "welfare-utilitarian" formulation. I answer a number of critical objections to welfare utilitarianism, and argue that the theory is most successful in facing the challenge of the ASO.
  Filename       Size       Approximate Download Time (Hours:Minutes:Seconds) 
 28.8 Modem   56K Modem   ISDN (64 Kb)   ISDN (128 Kb)   Higher-speed Access 
  EhnertThesis.pdf 210.17 Kb 00:00:58 00:00:30 00:00:26 00:00:13 00:00:01

Browse All Available ETDs by ( Author | Department )

dla home
etds imagebase journals news ereserve special collections
virgnia tech home contact dla university libraries

If you have questions or technical problems, please Contact DLA.