Communications Project

Document Type:Dissertation
Name:Mohammad Naim Yaakub
Title:Meta-Analysis of the Effectiveness of Computer-Assisted Instruction in Technical Education and Training
Degree:Doctor of Philosophy
Department:Teaching and Learning
Committee Chair: Curtis R. Finch
Committee Members:Patrick A. O'Reilly
Mark E. Sanders
Daisy L. Stewart
Mark A. Widdowson
Keywords:Computer-Assisted Instruction, Effectiveness, Meta-Analysis, Technical Training, Effect Size
Date of defense:June 22, 1998
Availability:Release the entire work for Virginia Tech access only.
After one year release worldwide only with written permission of the student and the advisory committee chair.


The overall effectiveness of computer-assisted instruction (CAI) for higher order learning in technical education and training was determined through the meta-analysis approach. Studies that had investigated the effectiveness of CAI as compared to traditional instruction were selected from major databases in the civilian and military sectors. The selection criteria were: (a) instruction was in the area of technical education and training, (b) a comparison was made between a group of students that received computer-assisted instruction with another group that was taught in the traditional manner, (c) student learning in both groups was measured in some form, and (d) quantitative results on criterion measures were provided. The common comparison metric chosen to indicate the effect size was the standardized mean difference. Additionally, a determination was made of the difference in CAI effectiveness between studies categorized into: (a) CAI type -- intelligent CAI and ordinary CAI; (b) nature of CAI treatment -- replacement and supplemental; (c) subject assignment -- random groups, intact groups, and assignments other than the preceding two groups; (d) educational level -- secondary / postsecondary, university, and adult military training; and (e) setting -- civilian and military. The overall effect size of CAI was found to be 0.35, implying that the average student in the traditional class would have improved from the 50th percentile to the 64th percentile if the student had been provided with CAI. Intelligent CAI was found to be significantly more effective than ordinary CAI.

List of Attached Files

Acknowledgment.pdf Chapter_I.pdf Chapter_II.pdf
Chapter_III.pdf Chapter_IV.pdf Chapter_V.pdf
Dedication.pdf References.pdf Vita.pdf

At the author's request, all materials (PDF files, images, etc.) associated with this ETD are accessible from the Virginia Tech network only.

The author grants to Virginia Tech or its agents the right to archive and display their thesis or dissertation in whole or in part in the University Libraries in all forms of media, now or hereafter known. The author retains all proprietary rights, such as patent rights. The author also retains the right to use in future works (such as articles or books) all or part of this thesis or dissertation.